Coccia House Pizza in Wooster

Coccia House Pizza in Wooster
4 / 5
49 reviews

764 Pittsburg AveWooster OH 44691, Wooster

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza

Restaurant Hours

Monday

5:00 pm - 11:00 pm

Tuesday

Closed

Wednesday

5:00 pm - 11:00 pm

Thursday

5:00 pm - 11:00 pm

Friday

5:00 pm - 12:00 am

Saturday

5:00 pm - 11:00 pm

Sunday

Closed

How to continue cooking a half bake pizza

I had two pizzas shipped to me in SC and no directions were provided. I called and was told to cook them at 450, without cheese, for 15 minutes. Then add cheese and cook for 10-15 more minutes. That worked perfectly.

do.they have take and bake pizza?

Yeah. It's called half baked with the cheese handed to you separately.

Do you offer a gluten free pizza?

You have to make the gluten free crust at home and take it to them. They will add toppings & cook.

Can u ship/mail out of state

Shipping starts at $80. It's sent next day air via FedEx and they only ship a couple times per week. You won't know the total until day of shipping and only if you call back to ask.

Is Coccia House open to dine in?

When you get a half baked they come without cheese on top. You add it at home.. You can move toppings attend. We got a plain, pepperoni, and sausage, mushrooms, and pepperoni. What we ended up with at home was a pepperoni with extra meat, a mushroom, and a mushroom and sausage. I would suggest that was as good as if we had not moved stuff around. The half baked are 90% as good as dine in.

I have tried calling the last 2 weekend's. Are they on vacation or something?

They always take a two week vacation in August . Sadly Joe , the owner did just pass away right before their break .

Do they take reservations?

Yes

When are you closed for vacation this summer?

You need to call them and ask. We are volunteers, not usually employees answering questions. Closing for vacation has differed in length and times during summers.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Coccia House Pizza
Savannah
google
11.21.2024
4/5

Called right at open on a Saturday night and already was at a 2 hour wait for pizza pick up. Got there and waited about another 15-20 minutes but enjoyed the craziness of all the people coming and going. The pizza is worth the wait, I promise! The anti-pasta is a favorite also!

Coccia House Pizza
lP
laura Pixie
google
10.14.2018
3/5

Food was good. Service was okay. Wait for food was excessive.

Coccia House Pizza
PB
Patricia Ballesteros
google
10.13.2018
5/5

It was a surprise in town this place. Great and delicious pizza. I will back soon. I tried the works with extra cheese 👍👍

Coccia House Pizza
Chris
google
10.13.2018
1/5

Waited nearly 2 hours for pizza. There were 4 pizzas ordered in our party. We were told that the delay was due to one being burnt. Two of the four came out luke warm at best and one was cold. The other 3 were clearly made and placed in a warmer while the burnt one got remade. Pizza was nowhere near as good as it used to be. And to top it all off, no manager came out to apologize or anything. In fact, the whole staff acts like they are doing you a favor by allowing you to overpay for subpar pizza. Coccia House used to be great. Not anymore.

Coccia House Pizza
AS
Amber Silva
google
10.13.2018
1/5

Going back to visit my hometown, eating at this place is a must. Although Ive never been treated so rudely!! I tried being nice to the lady at the checkout and all I could get was mean faces and eye rolls, not sure if she hates her job or what! I guess customer service was never a strength for this restaurant. It was $50 for two pizzas. One pizza had raw slimy dough, I was not impressed! I miss the good ole days with the crispy buttery crust! The wait was 1 1/2 hrs when I picked up my pizza it was room temp 😞 Better luck next time 🤞

Coccia House Pizza
TB
Trevor Bannavong
google
09.13.2018
5/5

Stopped by for a late night dinner. Pizza was great and staff was very friendly. Prices were fair and they offer free refills on soft drinks. They also serve crafty beers and good wines. The setting and feel of the restaurant feels very warm and cozy. Definitely will be coming to eat in more often.

Coccia House Pizza
TR
Terry Reeves
google
08.20.2018
5/5

Best pizza ever but long wait to get one but worth it

Coccia House Pizza
JS
J Seal
google
08.07.2018
5/5

The sausage and pepperoni is so delicious. We always had Coccia house pizza growing up, my Grandma Zarlengo was great friends with the Coccia family and it was right up the hill from her house. 😍🍕

Coccia House Pizza
RQ
Renee Qamar
google
07.11.2018
5/5

This is positively the most unique and delicious pizza known to man! Homemade and fresh ingredients, and a wonderful family legacy support this wonderful landmark in Wooster., Ohio. Definitely a destination spot if you are in the area.

Coccia House Pizza
superbeef150
google
06.17.2018
5/5

You'll either love it or hate it. Tons of garlic. Expect a long wait especially on the weekends, but if you like the food and know that ahead of time it's worth it.

Coccia House Pizza
AL
Andrew Latshaw
google
05.10.2018
5/5

It's a Wooster thing! Growing up in Wooster there are 3 staples to life! Coccia House, Hero House, and the Wayne County Fair. Having been gone from Wooster for years, I needed to reconnect with my childhood roots! Love the pizza!

Coccia House Pizza
DP
Dave Perez
google
05.03.2018
5/5

This is my all time favorite pizza. Unlike any pizza you have ever had. Be ready for a ride to flavor town. 😁

Coccia House Pizza
MM
Michelle Miller
google
04.23.2018
5/5

Lived around the corner. Smells were delightful. Even with a wine bar in back, pickup customers constantly streaming in and park nearby, never a fight, polluted or crowded Street. Dining room cozy and warm. Food-thick cheese smothered pizzas, addictive red sauce that tasted like Italy, and classy hor d erves like procutto with cantalope. The sweetest most efficient staff. Lots of parking.

Coccia House Pizza
BE
Brent Eklin
google
03.26.2018
5/5

Hands down the best. No more info needed. Double pep and double cheese.

Coccia House Pizza
MK
Matt Kruit
google
03.23.2018
3/5

The pizza is definitely one of a kind and very good. I just wish they were open more often. The hours are strange but it is worth it.

Coccia House Pizza
AG
Allison Golombos
google
01.10.2018
3/5

Recommended to us by a couple people so, when we were down that direction, we went. This was a Saturday, but we got there just as they opened. Pretty loud place and, sorry to say, I was not jazzed on their pizza. Ordered an appetizer (bruchetta) which came on untoasted bread -- so the balsamic on it just kind of made the bread wet. And these were two big pieces -- which I never saw before: like they took two pieces of Italian bread and dripped some balsamic over it and threw on a couple chunks of tomato. Also served it with BLEU CHEESE! Gross! Best part of our meal was the salads -- which were very basic. But they were fresh.

Coccia House Pizza
ts
tom smail
google
11.27.2017
5/5

Love this place. Best pizza ever, hands down. We have been ordering from them, as a family tradition, for as long as I can remember. Well worth the wait & the 30min drive for me. I often tell people they need to go here at least once in there lifetime. I will continue ordering from here as long as I possibly can.

Coccia House Pizza
SH
Samantha Hood
google
11.27.2017
5/5

Another must visit place if you come to Wooster. They have weird hours but for sure worth the wait. Family owned. If you call and the lines are busy try again so worth it. It will take awhile to get your pizza they are always busy so plan ahead and do not call last minute!!

Coccia House Pizza
LM
Linda Morosko
google
11.23.2017
2/5

Great atmosphere. Clearly a favorite of the locals. Went for my son's birthday. A place he likes. He and my hubby loved the pizza. I did not. The crust on my pizza was hard and dry. Not appetizing. They had many other dishes in the menu. Next time, I'll try one of those.

Coccia House Pizza
CP
Cody Pamer
google
11.20.2017
1/5

Called and ordered at 5.15 and got there at 6.15 and still wasn't ready waited until 6.45 .. really wanted to try this place and it's the grossest pizza I've ever had ..sauce is bland and taste like garbage and honestly its disgusting. After waiting 1hr and a half and having the pizza suck I will never go back

Coccia House Pizza
SN
Sharon North
google
10.08.2017
5/5

Best pizza ever. We now live 1 hour away and it’s the only pizza we eat. Well worth the drive

Coccia House Pizza
BM
Bruce Mapes
google
10.04.2017
3/5

Very slow service and soup was cold. Great pizza. Five stars for pizza, one star for service.

Coccia House Pizza
rr
ray ritchey
google
09.13.2017
5/5

Best pizza in Ohio's

Coccia House Pizza
VT
Valerie Taylor
google
09.02.2017
5/5

Coccia House is amazing!! The best pizza in Wooster! Nice staff, clean restaurant, they don't cross contaminate their food like some other places. We got to meet the owner as well, very nice gentleman! Try their bruschetta!!!!

Coccia House Pizza
nidan206
google
08.27.2017
2/5

This place is a hit or miss. Had great pizza once, so went back. Second time I just about threw up it was so disgusting. Minus a star for that bad pizza, minus an other star because they don't take debit. Minus a 3rd star because older lady was curt when I was purchasing a gift certificate from her.

Coccia House Pizza
CM
Claudia Montgomery
google
08.16.2017
4/5

Pizza was good waitress was good but the wait for the food was way to long . I Under Stand they were extremely busy and it was a sat night at dinner hour but waiting two and half hours for 2 large pizza was little extreme. Plus we had 2 small children with us. Why did we do it? We heard how delicious they were and wanted to try them

Coccia House Pizza
TW
Thomas Weiser
google
08.16.2017
2/5

We’ve been getting pizza here for 30 years. There is no other like it. However since Joe’s passing, not only us but I’ve heard many other people make comments such as how much thinner the crusts are being made and all the other ingredients have been decreased in the amount on the pizzas. Eventually people will look elsewhere for pizza. Getting cheap on the ingredients and charging more for the pizzas will eventually come back and bite you. I would rather you raise the prices again than cut back on ingredients!

Coccia House Pizza
JC
Jeannette Crilow
google
06.27.2017
5/5

Love Coccia House. The best pizza❤️

Coccia House Pizza
CH
Cindy Hockenberry
google
05.01.2017
5/5

I grew up eating this pizza and love it! I can only eat one piece as they really pile on the toppings. Other places you can count the pepperoni at first glance. The deluxe with extra cheese and bricked is the best! Was sorry to hear that Sam had recently passed. It was always so nice to see him at the register. I hope nothing changes and they keep making the best pizza in Wooster!

Coccia House Pizza
DR
Donna Recktenwalt
google
03.25.2017
5/5

This was our first time there. We ordered a pizza with side salads and a bottle of a semi-sweet red wine. The pizza was fantastic. Nice and garlicky, the way we like it and plenty of toppings and cheese. And I found my new favorite red wine there! The Dornfelder was the perfect amount of sweetness, not too sweet, and wonder flavor.

Coccia House Pizza
TB
Tim Badger
google
03.25.2017
5/5

Just WOW , for the Pizza Lover.. A well know local place, but no secret the wide variety of authentic Italian food here is incredible.

Coccia House Pizza
BF
Brad Fisher
google
03.21.2017
4/5

I miss Joe, he always made sure your order was done right, now since he is gone it has changed. This use to be one of the best places in town. Wait time is way to long, that's Always been a problem, the sauce was kinda watered down and crust was thinner and kind of on the hard side. I have talked with others and they agree, it has definitely changed since the loss of Joe, he was always very pleasant. I plan on trying again, maybe just a bad night. I don't know..

Coccia House Pizza
C
google
03.15.2017
5/5

Grew up eating this pizza. It's the best!! No one else compares! I drive an hour to get it.

Coccia House Pizza
IR
Isaac Roth
google
03.13.2017
3/5

I guess a lot of people really like this pizza. I must not be one of those people.

Coccia House Pizza
DG
Deanna Gage
google
03.10.2017
5/5

Best pizza. One of a kind

Coccia House Pizza
DL
Dennis Lockhart
google
02.24.2017
5/5

World class pizza!

Coccia House Pizza
DL
Dylan Liebhart
google
02.18.2017
4/5

The atmosphere here is great and the staff are kind and caring. The food here is extremely good and filling. You get your money's worth. The only complaint I have is that it took a while for us to get our pizza, though you have to understand that not only are they cooking the pizza instead of sending it through an oven that baked pizzas in 7 minutes, they are always swamped with orders. This is a good place for you to sit down and have a meal with family or friends.

Coccia House Pizza
JJ
Jill Justice
google
02.07.2017
4/5

Wonderful service. Food was absolutely magnificent! Wait time could be better but it's worth it for what they have to offer.

Coccia House Pizza
WM
Will Moine
google
02.03.2017
1/5

We dined in the dining room and our pizza with everything was brought to the table with the center raw and a soupy mess. When you removed one piece the toppings oozed off the rest of the pizza on to the pan. Definitely not worth the wait.

Coccia House Pizza
JH
Jim Hartman
google
01.25.2017
5/5

The pizza was hot and delicious. If you like the cheese on top, this is the place for you.

Coccia House Pizza
HG
Heather Gress
google
11.22.2016
5/5

Amazing as always, take and bake is the way to go.

Coccia House Pizza
DB
Douglas Bing
google
09.16.2016
5/5

Best pizza I grew up with it ! You won't be dissapointed

Coccia House Pizza
JH
Joe Hiltabidel
google
09.10.2016
4/5

Mixed bag. These guys could be millionaires if they franchised. The pizza is great, always has been. Pepperoni is spicy, sauce is unique and well seasoned, crust is crispy and pizza comes with heavy mozzarella. But we can't seem to figure out why it takes so long to get in, to get a phone call in, to get the food. It's like they have one oven and it's an easy bake oven for kids. They don't take credit cards in the restaurant but if you have pizzas shipped, they take credit cards. I gotta believe that so they don't have to report all of their income.

Coccia House Pizza
EC
Evan Carl
google
09.07.2016
5/5

Real authentic pizza. This place is in a league of their own. Everything is made from scratch and it really shows. Amazing! I can hardly wait to go back.

Coccia House Pizza
SS
Stephanie Sczpanski
google
07.03.2016
5/5

All time favorite pizza! Love it!

Coccia House Pizza
PR
Peggy Rupp
google
05.11.2016
4/5

Waiting time for pizza beyond un acceptable. Been patrons over 50 yrs everytime we go it gets worse and we question our sanity. We try to support local and give back they have given so much. Getting half baked isnt so bad order a day ahead

Coccia House Pizza
huntinglifecd
google
04.21.2016
5/5

The best pizza I have ever had

Coccia House Pizza
BM
Bob Mote
google
04.09.2016
5/5

I love this Pizza.... I grew up on it, I live in Las Vegas now but anytime I get job near Wooster I make that trip n get pizza for me and my employees.... 6hrs driving today but it IS worth it👍👍👍

Coccia House Pizza
JH
Joseph Hodges
google
03.24.2016
2/5

Heard so many great things about this place figured we give it a try ...our insurance agency office went down to have dinner on Wednesday night and of course the usual fare of pizza was served and it looked awesome ...the wife and I decided to get a couple dinner platter’s... ordered the big daddy pasta and it looked my eight-year-old granddaughter put it together... very poor very small pasta dish...was extremely watery...flavor was OK...anyway stay away from everything on the menu that is not marked pizza and you should be OK.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 13302627136

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!